Loading imagePeter Schiff says Solana can replace Bitcoin exposure. Can it? - 1

Share

Peter Schiff has used the recovery in cryptocurrency prices to argue that investors can buy Solana if they expect Bitcoin to rise. Recent trading supports part of his argument, but the losses, supply rules and reasons for owning the two assets tell a more complicated story.

• Bitcoin and Solana moved in the same direction on 15 of 18 daily observations between Nov. 3 and Nov. 21.

• Bitcoin lost 22.3% over the comparison period, while Solana fell 24.3%, leaving equal starting investments with different balances.

• CoinGecko recorded gains of 155.2% for Bitcoin and 917.3% for Solana in 2023, showing how far their returns can diverge.

• Bitcoin’s 21 million supply ceiling differs from Solana’s issuance model, which retains a 1.5% terminal inflation rate.

• Solana’s 67% vote for faster disinflation approved a policy direction, while implementation and activation determine when issuance actually changes.

Bitcoin and Solana have moved in the same direction on 15 of the last 18 completed daily return observations, giving Peter Schiff’s argument about buying SOL for exposure to a Bitcoin rally some support during a month in which both assets have suffered heavy losses.

In a Nov. 21 post about Bitcoin, Schiff argued that investors did not need to own BTC to benefit from its recovery because major cryptocurrencies traded together. He singled out Solana before using that relationship to challenge Bitcoin’s claim to scarcity.

The comparison comes after a punishing stretch for both markets, followed by a recovery that has left investors weighing whether the selling has run its course. Buying the coin that might recover fastest is one decision; choosing an asset to hold through the next market cycle involves several others.

A comparison of matching daily closes shows why Schiff’s argument deserves a closer look, without establishing that the two assets are interchangeable. SOL followed Bitcoin’s direction frequently, but an investor who bought Solana at the start of the period still ended with a larger percentage loss.

Schiff’s argument starts with the rebound

“If you think Bitcoin will go up, you can buy Solana instead,” Schiff wrote, before concluding: “That makes Bitcoin less scarce.”

His post was framed as a criticism of Bitcoin, not a disclosure that he had bought SOL or changed his view of cryptocurrencies. Presenting it as a personal recommendation to replace Bitcoin with Solana would go beyond what he said.

Schiff has continued to question Bitcoin’s investment case during the recent decline. As crypto.news reported in its earlier Bitcoin warning, he argued on Nov. 10 that BTC’s failure to follow a Wall Street recovery left it vulnerable to another selloff.

His latest argument moves from Bitcoin’s failure to follow stocks to its tendency to trade alongside other cryptocurrencies. The suggestion is that someone expecting a cryptocurrency recovery could buy another large token and still participate in the move.

For a trader whose only objective is to make money from rising crypto prices, that is a reasonable possibility to investigate. Such a trader may care more about how much SOL rises during the next rally than about whether the position contains any Bitcoin.

The difficulty begins when a possibility becomes a promise. Schiff’s wording assumes that getting Bitcoin’s direction right will mean getting Solana’s direction right, although that relationship has no contractual or protocol guarantee.

Owning SOL gives the holder an asset native to Solana, with its own market, issuance and network risks. It does not give the holder a claim on BTC, a redemption right for Bitcoin or a return fixed to Bitcoin’s price.

A trader can therefore be right that the two markets often respond together and still be wrong about the return earned from switching between them. The latest daily closes provide a way to examine that difference before turning to the scarcity argument.

JUST IN: An estimated $17 trillion wiped from global stocks, crypto and precious metals in a single week The massive decline came as Bitcoin dipped to a low of $55,000 before rebounfing above $60,000. pic.twitter.com/raAdNAssic — crypto.news (@cryptodotnews) November 22, 2026

The prices often move together, but the money does not match

For this comparison, matching completed daily closes were taken from CoinGecko’s Bitcoin historical prices and Solana historical prices, covering Nov. 3 through Nov. 21. Nineteen closing prices produce 18 daily percentage changes; the incomplete Nov. 22 observation was excluded.

Bitcoin fell from $77,385 to $60,121 over that period, while SOL declined from $92.78 to $70.20. The resulting losses were 22.3% and 24.3%, respectively, before trading costs, taxes or any staking rewards.

Daily returns had a correlation of approximately 0.88, calculated from those 18 matching observations. A positive reading that close to one indicates that the moves were strongly associated within this sample, although it does not establish that one asset caused the other to move.

Both coins rose or fell together on 15 days. On the remaining three, the direction differed, although two involved very small changes that make the simple up-or-down count less informative than it first appears.

The figures support the narrower part of Schiff’s argument: Solana provided exposure to much of the same market direction during this selloff. They do not show that SOL reliably delivered Bitcoin’s return, or that the relationship will survive a different market environment.

The hypothetical investments start with the same dollar amount and remain unleveraged throughout. Solana finishes about $203 behind Bitcoin, even though the two assets usually traded in the same direction.

Individual sessions show why that gap cannot be understood by counting green and red days alone. On Nov. 17, Bitcoin’s daily close rose about 0.07%, while Solana gained approximately 5.03%.

On Nov. 14, both were lower, but Bitcoin fell about 6.1% and Solana dropped roughly 10.2%. A buyer who correctly anticipated weakness in the overall market would still have faced quite different losses depending on the asset held.

Across the sample, SOL’s daily return volatility was about 38% higher than Bitcoin’s, using the sample standard deviation of daily percentage changes. Equal dollar positions therefore did not carry the same observed day-to-day price risk.

The result also depends on choosing the same entry and exit dates. Comparing Bitcoin from the beginning of its decline with Solana from a later low would make the apparent alternative look stronger without describing a trade available on equal terms.

Daily closes leave out movements within each session. A leveraged trader could be forced out during an intraday drop even if the closing price later recovers, so these unleveraged figures cannot describe the outcome of a futures position.

The comparison is limited to a short, falling market and should not be read as a permanent relationship between the assets. Eighteen returns are enough to describe this stretch of trading, but insufficient to establish how either coin will behave through another cycle.

Nor does a correlation of 0.88 mean Solana has an 88% chance of rising whenever Bitcoin rises. The statistic measures how returns varied together in the selected observations; it supplies neither a probability of the next gain nor a forecast of its size.

Solana has delivered much more than a Bitcoin-like return before

A period in which SOL loses slightly more than Bitcoin does not capture the full attraction of Schiff’s suggested trade. Solana buyers can be seeking a much larger recovery, with the expectation that accepting more risk will produce more upside when market conditions improve.

CoinGecko’s 2023 annual report recorded a 155.2% gain for Bitcoin and a 917.3% gain for Solana. Both rose sharply, but the difference was large enough to make the choice between them central to the investment outcome.

Those annual gains give the strongest historical support to someone considering SOL as an alternative way to participate in a rising crypto market. They also show why describing it simply as Bitcoin exposure can conceal the separate bet being made.

An investor who chose SOL in that year bought into a recovery far stronger than Bitcoin’s. The same investor could not have secured that additional return merely by observing that the two prices sometimes rose together.

The report described Solana’s recovery from the aftermath of FTX’s collapse alongside renewed interest in its ecosystem and airdrops. Those were Solana-related developments, making its performance more than a mechanical response to Bitcoin’s price.

JUST IN: Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer still favors Bitcoin over gold He says BTC is showing relative strength despite the recent sell-off in both assets. pic.twitter.com/3ODEzt5XXP — crypto.news (@cryptodotnews) November 7, 2026

A single exceptional year does not establish what SOL will return during the next recovery. It does establish that a substitute selected for its upside may behave very differently from the asset it is supposed to replace.

The November comparison gives the other side of that choice. SOL ended the period with a larger dollar loss and lost approximately 2.6% against Bitcoin itself, measured by the change in the SOL-to-BTC price ratio.

A dollar recovery can therefore leave a Solana holder behind a Bitcoin holder if BTC rises faster. Someone judging the switch only by whether their SOL position is profitable could miss that the original Bitcoin holding would have been worth more.

Recent reporting has shown that SOL has faced selling pressure of its own. crypto.news reported its slide below $70 on Nov. 20, when the token gave up much of an earlier recovery and traded near its recent lows.

A benchmark chosen after the event can make almost any successful position sound like a substitute for something else. For the person deciding today, the useful benchmark is the asset they would otherwise hold, assessed from the date the decision is made.

If the intended alternative is Bitcoin, a dollar profit alone is insufficient to establish that switching worked. The investor needs to compare the value of the SOL position with the BTC position forgone, using the same dates and including the costs of the change.

The relevant question for a prospective buyer is consequently more demanding than whether Bitcoin will rise. It includes whether Solana will attract enough demand to match or exceed that move, and how much additional loss the buyer is prepared to accept if it does not.

Competition for investors does not increase Bitcoin’s supply

Schiff’s final claim moves beyond market performance into the meaning of scarcity. Investors can choose another cryptocurrency, but that does not increase the number of bitcoins issued by the Bitcoin network.

Bitcoin’s published monetary rules describe declining issuance and a ceiling of 21 million BTC. Solana transactions do not create units within that supply, and SOL cannot be presented to the Bitcoin network as if it were native BTC.

Those rules are enforced through the software participants choose to run. They are not a promise that every asset competing with Bitcoin will disappear, or that investors will always prefer BTC when other opportunities are available.

Schiff’s criticism has more force when applied to demand. A buyer with a fixed amount of money can choose Solana, Bitcoin, gold, equities or cash, and competition for that money can affect how much any one asset is worth.

A limited supply is compatible with falling prices if demand weakens. Bitcoin’s supply ceiling does not put a floor under its market price, protect an entry price or guarantee that its holder will outperform someone who chose another asset.

Bitcoin.org’s own explanation ties value to people’s willingness to use and accept bitcoin. Scarcity is part of the investment argument, but it cannot settle the demand question on its own.

The distinction leaves room for disagreement about valuation without confusing separate supplies. Solana can compete for money that might otherwise have bought Bitcoin while remaining unable to issue, settle or redeem native BTC.

Investors who value Bitcoin primarily for its supply policy may therefore regard SOL as an unsuitable replacement even when their prices move together. Someone primarily seeking a profitable rally can reach a different decision without proving that Bitcoin’s supply policy has changed.

The same distinction applies to the price of one coin. SOL’s lower dollar quotation does not by itself make it cheaper than Bitcoin, because the networks have different numbers of units and different issuance arrangements.

Bitcoin can also be purchased in fractions, so a buyer does not need enough money for one whole BTC to own it. Comparing the sticker price of one SOL with one bitcoin therefore says little about the relative value of equal dollar investments.

Solana’s issuance creates another decision for holders

Solana’s supply policy is part of its own investment case, particularly for holders deciding whether to stake their tokens. Its model includes continuing issuance, with a terminal inflation rate of 1.5%, instead of Bitcoin’s eventual end to new issuance.

In August, Solana’s inflation proposal vote passed with approximately 67% support. The measure backed a faster decline in inflation while retaining that terminal rate.

The underlying double disinflation proposal would increase the annual reduction in the inflation rate from 15% to 30%. It changes how quickly issuance approaches the existing floor, not whether Solana acquires a Bitcoin-style maximum supply.

A governance result is separate from a live change to network issuance. Approval, client implementation and activation are different steps, and the vote alone cannot establish the inflation rate applying on a later date.

The sources reviewed for this feature establish the approved direction but do not independently verify its activation by Nov. 22. Quoting the proposal’s modeled timetable as an already achieved reduction would therefore overstate what has been confirmed.

For holders, the practical distinction involves participation as well as supply. A person holding unstaked SOL receives no staking rewards simply because the network issues new tokens, while a staker can receive rewards under the network’s arrangements.

Rewards increase the number of SOL held but do not fix their dollar value. A falling market can leave a staker with more tokens and a portfolio worth less than when the position began.

A comparison with Bitcoin should consequently use consistent returns. Comparing SOL’s price gain plus staking rewards with Bitcoin’s price gain can be useful, provided the rewards, costs and period are stated; comparing an advertised staking rate with an uncertain Bitcoin price gain answers a different question.

Our November calculation uses prices alone for both assets. It does not assume a validator, a particular staking arrangement or a reward rate, avoiding a yield estimate that might not apply to the person making the comparison.

Staking can strengthen the case for someone already prepared to own SOL, but it does not turn the holding into Bitcoin. The return still depends on Solana’s market price, issuance and the conditions under which the holder earns and accesses the rewards.

Solana has reasons to rise that do not begin with Bitcoin

Solana’s supporters do not need to rely entirely on the argument that Bitcoin will drag the rest of crypto higher. SOL is used to pay for transactions on a network that supports applications, token transfers and other activity.

That creates a separate question about demand for the network and the token required to use it. A buyer convinced that Solana will gain users is making a claim about Solana’s future, even if Bitcoin’s price is part of the market backdrop.

Under Solana’s transaction fee rules, the base fee is 5,000 lamports per signature, with half burned and half paid to the validator. Priority fees go entirely to the validator.

Those details matter when activity figures are used to support a price forecast. An increase in transactions does not mean that every fee is burned or that all network spending flows to every person holding SOL.

For illustration, one million transactions carrying one signature each would produce 5 SOL in base fees under that rate, with 2.5 SOL burned. The calculation is hypothetical and excludes priority fees and other charges; it is not a measurement of daily network revenue.

A busy application can therefore be relevant to demand without supplying a simple equation between transaction count and token appreciation. The investment outcome still depends on what users spend, how the system distributes that spending and what investors are willing to pay for SOL.

Bitcoin’s investment case has a different emphasis, including demand to hold and transfer an asset with limited issuance. That does not prevent Bitcoin from being used for payments or Solana from being held as a long-term investment.

It does mean that the networks need not attract buyers for identical reasons. A change that makes Solana applications more attractive can matter to SOL holders without creating the same demand for Bitcoin.

The possibility works in both directions. If enthusiasm for Solana’s applications weakens while demand for Bitcoin holds up, a positive historical correlation will not compel the markets to deliver matching returns.

Buying SOL because of its network prospects can be a coherent investment thesis. Calling the position Bitcoin exposure risks obscuring the development, adoption and competitive assumptions that make the Solana thesis stand or fall.

The network behind the position still matters

A price chart cannot show every risk involved in using either asset. A holder may eventually need to transfer funds, access an application or move coins to an exchange, making the condition of the underlying network relevant even if the original purchase was a short-term trade.

Solana’s history includes a five-hour network outage on Feb. 6, 2024. Operations resumed after a software upgrade and a coordinated validator restart, according to reporting at the time.

That incident is historical, not evidence that Solana is currently halted. It remains relevant to a comparison that treats native SOL and BTC as interchangeable assets, because an interruption can affect what a holder can do while prices continue changing elsewhere.

The network has since undergone major development. crypto.news reported the Alpenglow upgrade timetable before its scheduled October launch, including the target of substantially faster transaction finality.

Solana’s Alpenglow implementation update now identifies the Votor voting protocol as live since epoch 1064 on Oct. 21. It describes a roughly 150-millisecond finality target, while Rotor, the planned block-distribution component, remains for a later release.

Faster finality can improve the experience of making payments or using applications, but it is not a promise of a higher token price. Nor does the deployment of one component establish that every planned part of the upgrade has shipped.

Bitcoin and Solana also use different approaches to securing their networks: proof of work and proof of stake. Comparing them requires attention to the costs, incentives and operational dependencies of each system, beyond the observation that their exchange prices often move together.

Bitcoin’s supply ceiling does not eliminate software, custody or network risks. Solana’s application capacity does not eliminate them either, and a buyer should distinguish the native token from additional services built around it.

A person holding SOL in a wallet has not automatically accepted every smart-contract risk on Solana. Depositing that SOL into a lending protocol, trading through an application or receiving a staking derivative adds arrangements that must be assessed separately.

Exchange custody creates another layer for either asset. A market recovery cannot remove the risk that an intermediary restricts withdrawals, loses funds or fails to deliver the coins a customer expects to own.

A substitute for a trade is not a substitute for every purpose

The evidence leaves a qualified case for Schiff’s trade and a much weaker case for treating SOL as Bitcoin itself. Someone expecting a general cryptocurrency recovery can choose Solana as a way to express that view, accepting that the result may be better or worse than owning BTC.

The November observations make that possibility tangible: the markets usually moved together, while the losses and volatility differed. The 2023 figures show that the gap can become enormous in a rising market, which is an attraction for some buyers and a warning against assuming equivalent exposure.

For a holder whose purpose is to own native Bitcoin under Bitcoin’s issuance rules, SOL does not meet the requirement. It cannot satisfy a Bitcoin-denominated payment or a requirement for native BTC without first being sold or exchanged on terms available at the time.

A switch can also leave the investor exposed to costs before either asset moves. Trading spreads, fees and any applicable tax consequences reduce the usefulness of a comparison based solely on closing prices, particularly if the holder repeatedly moves between the coins.

Those costs vary by venue and jurisdiction, so they have not been assigned a universal number here. Their omission from the hypothetical portfolio should not be mistaken for an assumption that switching is free.

Holding both assets is a separate decision again. The positive relationship observed in November means that adding SOL did not reliably provide an offset when Bitcoin fell, even though the positions represented different networks.

Whether a different mix reduces portfolio risk requires a longer comparison and a stated investment period. The small sample used here cannot establish an optimal allocation, and its volatility figures should not be converted into a permanent rule for sizing trades. A larger SOL position selected to chase a stronger rebound would change the comparison again, exposing more money to that asset’s separate risks.

An obligation stated in BTC makes the distinction especially clear. If someone will need to deliver a particular quantity of bitcoin later, a SOL position leaves them exposed to the exchange rate between the assets, even if both gain against the dollar.

A holder measuring wealth in dollars has a different concern, since either asset can produce a dollar loss. Deciding which return matters before entering the trade makes it harder to mistake a shared rebound for success against the original objective.

The lower quoted price of SOL does not resolve either problem. For an equal dollar investment, the percentage change determines the price-only outcome, not how many whole coins appear in the wallet or how far each coin sits below Bitcoin’s quotation.

Staking introduces one final practical difference between buying SOL for a quick move and committing it to earn rewards. According to Solana’s stake account documentation, delegation and deactivation do not take effect immediately, with stake becoming active or inactive at epoch boundaries and timing dependent on network-wide limits.

What to Watch

• Return relationship: Compare matching daily BTC and SOL returns over longer periods to determine whether November’s strong association persists outside the selloff.

• Relative performance: Follow the SOL-to-BTC ratio alongside dollar prices to see whether a Solana recovery actually outpaces holding Bitcoin over the same dates.

• Issuance activation: Check client releases and network activation evidence for the approved disinflation change before treating the proposal’s modeled supply reductions as live outcomes.

• Network delivery: Track the performance of live Alpenglow components and any confirmed schedule for Rotor, separating deployed changes from development plans.

• Staking conditions: Check the chosen validator, fees and withdrawal timing before comparing a staked SOL position with liquid Bitcoin held over the same period.

FAQs

Did Peter Schiff recommend buying Solana?

Schiff used Solana to argue that investors could participate in a Bitcoin rally without owning BTC. His post was a criticism of Bitcoin’s scarcity argument, not evidence that he had purchased SOL or adopted a favorable view of cryptocurrencies.

Can Solana provide exposure to a Bitcoin rally?

It can participate in the same market move, and the two assets traded in the same direction on 15 of the 18 daily observations examined here. The relationship does not guarantee that SOL will rise whenever Bitcoin rises or deliver the same percentage return. A buyer still accepts Solana-specific price and network risks.

What did the November comparison show?

Matching daily closes from Nov. 3 through Nov. 21 produced a return correlation of about 0.88. Bitcoin lost 22.3% and Solana lost 24.3%, demonstrating that strongly associated daily moves can still leave investors with different cumulative outcomes.

Does buying Solana make Bitcoin less scarce?

Buying SOL does not create additional BTC or change Bitcoin’s 21 million issuance ceiling. Solana can compete for investment money, which affects demand, but competition between assets and the supply of native bitcoins are separate matters.

Has Solana outperformed Bitcoin before?

Yes. CoinGecko recorded a 917.3% gain for SOL in 2023, compared with Bitcoin’s 155.2% gain. Those historical results describe that particular year and do not establish the winner of the next rally. They show the scale of possible divergence, not a dependable return multiple.

Does Solana have a maximum supply like Bitcoin?

Solana’s issuance model retains a 1.5% terminal inflation rate instead of a Bitcoin-style maximum. The approved faster-disinflation policy changes the path toward that rate, with live effects dependent on implementation and activation.

Do staking rewards protect a SOL holding from losses?

Rewards can increase the number of tokens held, but they do not protect the dollar value of those tokens. A complete comparison should include the reward received, price changes, fees and the conditions governing access to staked funds.

Is Solana a suitable replacement for Bitcoin?

That depends on the purpose of the holding: participation in a crypto rally differs from ownership of native BTC and its supply policy. SOL introduces a separate investment case and can produce substantially different returns. This is educational analysis, not investment advice.

Disclaimer: This article is for information and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Figures reflect market data and reporting available at the time of writing and change as markets move and providers update their disclosures. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or asset. Always do your own research. Information is accurate as of Nov. 22, 2026. Consult a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.